1

Extra cheese

Image: Ivan Torres

Let's start with a wild card: extra cheese pizza. It's no surprise it's one of the most popular choices, with its unbeatable trio of classic ingredients: dough, a lot of mozzarella cheese, and a simple tomato sauce. And who doesn't like cheese?

However, its simplicity doesn't make it any less delicious; it can be one of the best pizzas you'll ever taste! And if you want to try something new, some suggest swapping mozzarella for provolone.

2

Pepperoni

Image: Alan Hardman

A total winner of all rankings, pepperoni pizza is undoubtedly one of Americans' favorites. And that's no surprise at all. The combination of delicious melted cheese with a tasty tomato sauce and spicy, smoky pepperoni slices makes it an irresistible variety for most palates. Is it your favorite, too?

3

Sausage

Image: Nadya Spetnitskaya

Thanks to pizza's unlimited variety of toppings, you don't have to pick between protein and carbohydrates; you can enjoy both!

Sausage pizza is now a staple on the menus of many restaurants and pizza chains. And it's no wonder, given that it's one of the most popular choices among Americans. Traditionally, pizza-makers opt for Italian sausage, but you can always choose your favorite type!

4

Mushrooms

Image: Lavi Perchik

Along with pepperoni, sausage, and extra cheese, mushrooms are also one of the most popular pizza toppings in America.

Because of their versatility, mushrooms are a great choice to complement any pizza, whether it's a vegetarian or a meat pizza. In addition, they are a recommended topping for their flavor, nutritional value, and low-calorie content.

5

Green Peppers

Image: engin akyurt

Green peppers also make the top 5. If sausage isn't your choice or you follow a vegetarian diet, green pepper pizza is likely one of your favorites.

The crunchy texture and slightly sweet flavor of green peppers make a fantastic team with pizza crust and tomato sauce, making it one of the most popular.

6

Onions

Image: Adonyi Gábor

There is an alternative that's a must-have on any menu: onion pizza. Although it may not have as many staunch and expressive fans as other varieties, onion pizza is actually one of the most requested options across the country.

Onion, like tomato and cheese, is a widely used ingredient in Italian cuisine, making it a classic that's also included in other varieties and sauces.

7

Black olives

Image: Carissa Gan

Black olives have earned a spot in this ranking, as it is a very appreciated option for those who demand a briny touch on their pizza.

Some people hate them, others love them, but if you've never tried black olives on your pizza, we recommend giving it a shot. Many people have tried them and come back for more!

8

Fresh garlic

Image: Sébastien Marchand

Hand in hand with onion, garlic is a must when it comes to giving a punch of flavor to food. And pizza is no exception. In fact, fresh garlic pizza is also one of the most widely eaten pizzas in America.

While it may not have as large a fan base as other toppings, those who choose garlic as their favorite are incredibly loyal! This variety offers an exquisite combination: Often paired with mozzarella cheese and olive oil, garlic gives a unique touch.

9

Margherita

Image: Aldward Castillo

If we talk about perfect combinations, we can't leave out the legendary Margherita, a fabulous Italian pizza. Created in the 19th century in Naples, Italy, this pizza was invented especially for the Queen Margherita of Savoy, with flavors that represent the Italian flag: the green of the basil, the red of the tomato, and the white of the mozzarella cheese. Irresistible!

10

BBQ Chicken

Image: serjan midili

Chain restaurants and pizzerias wouldn't be the same without the delicious BBQ chicken pizza, a blend of flavor, heartiness, and creativity.

If the more traditional varieties have bored you, this is the perfect option for you. With a combination of sweet and smoky, this variety is undoubtedly a top choice for those who appreciate audacious tastes.

1

Hydrox Cookies

Image: Conor Brown

Introduced in 1908, these chocolate sandwich cookies with cream filling were the original, while Oreos followed four years later in 1912 . Hydrox had a crunchier cookie and a less sweet filling, which devoted fans absolutely loved.

Hydrox disappeared from shelves in 2003, leaving longtime fans heartbroken and insisting that they were superior to their more famous competitor. The cookie made a brief comeback in 2015 under new ownership, but it never quite recaptured its former glory or widespread availability.

2

Squeezit

Image: Haley Owens

Squeezit arrived on the scene in 1985 with its unique bottle design that you literally had to squeeze to drink from—no straw needed! The bottles came in wild colors and flavors like Chucklin' Cherry and Grumpy Grape, each with its own cartoon character printed on the label.

General Mills discontinued Squeezit in 2001, crushing the dreams of millennials everywhere who had fond memories of squeezing these bottles a little too hard and squirting juice everywhere.

3

Jell-O Pudding Pops

Image: sheri silver

Bill Cosby might have made these famous in commercials, but it was the frozen treat itself that made Pudding Pops legendary in the 1980s. Introduced in 1979, these weren't your typical popsicles— they had a creamy, mousse-like texture that was somewhere between pudding and ice cream.

Jell-O discontinued the original Pudding Pops in the early 1990s, and despite several attempted comebacks with different formulations, they've never tasted quite the same as the originals. People who remember the real deal insist that the modern versions just don't have that same creamy texture or rich flavor.

4

Crystal Pepsi

Image: Giorgio Trovato

Launched in 1992, this clear cola was supposed to represent "purity" and tap into the clear product craze of the era . It tasted almost exactly like regular Pepsi, which created a weird cognitive dissonance: your brain expected lemon-lime, but your taste buds got cola. Crystal Pepsi flopped hard and disappeared by 1994, but it achieved cult status among nostalgic millennials and Gen Xers.

5

Bonkers! Candy

Image: Edgar Chaparro

"Bonkers bonks you out!" went the commercial jingle, and this chewy fruit candy certainly made an impact when it hit stores in the early 1980s. Each piece was wrapped individually and packed an intensely fruity flavor that was almost overwhelming—in a good way . Bonkers came in flavors like grape, strawberry, and watermelon, and they had a unique texture that was chewier than Starburst but softer than taffy.

Nabisco stopped making Bonkers in the 1990s, and fruit candy lovers have been mourning ever since. There were brief periods when the candy reappeared under different ownership, but it never achieved the same widespread distribution.

6

Dunkaroos

Image: RUMEYSA AYDIN

Introduced by Betty Crocker in 1990, these snack packs came with small kangaroo-shaped cookies and a container of frosting for dipping. The concept was simple but brilliant—make cookies even more fun by turning them into an interactive snack. Flavors included chocolate chip cookies with vanilla frosting, vanilla cookies with chocolate frosting, and the ultimate combo of chocolate cookies with chocolate frosting.

General Mills discontinued Dunkaroos in the United States in 2012, sparking outrage among millennials who considered them a sacred part of their childhood. The good news? After years of petitions and social media campaigns, Dunkaroos made a triumphant return in 2020.

7

Clearly Canadian

Image: 소녀

Before sparkling water became trendy, there was Clearly Canadian— a flavored sparkling water that came in distinctive teardrop-shaped glass bottles . Launched in 1987, this Canadian import became hugely popular in the U.S. throughout the late 80s and 90s. The flavors had fancy names like Wild Cherry, Country Raspberry, and Orchard Peach, and the carbonation was more aggressive than today's LaCroix.

Clearly Canadian largely disappeared from American stores in the 2000s as other beverages dominated the market, though the company never completely shut down. Thanks to a Kickstarter campaign in 2015, it made a comeback, but it's still not as widely available as it once was.

8

P.B. Crisps

Image: Olga Nayda

Planters gave us the ultimate peanut butter snack in 1992 with P.B. Crisps— crispy shell-shaped cookies filled with peanut butter . These weren't ordinary peanut butter cookies; they had a unique, crispy texture on the outside and creamy peanut butter on the inside, creating a perfect contrast.

Sadly, P.B. Crisps were discontinued in 1995 after just three years on the market, leaving peanut butter lovers devastated. No snack has quite filled that void—Nutter Butters are too cookie-like, and peanut butter crackers are too cracker-like.

9

Altoids Sours

Image: Customerbox

These tiny, tangy candies came in flavors like Tangerine, Citrus, and Raspberry, and they packed a seriously sour punch that made your whole face scrunch up . They came in the same iconic tin as regular Altoids, which made them feel substantial and collectible.

Altoids discontinued the Sours in 2010, and fans have been petitioning for their return ever since. There have been multiple online petitions, Facebook groups, and even people hoarding old tins as collectors' items.

10

Snapple Elements

Image: Snappr

Launched in 1999, these drinks came in wide-mouthed glass bottles and had more exotic flavors than typical Snapple offerings . Rain was agave cactus, Sun was starfruit, and Fire was dragonfruit. The bottles themselves were beautiful, with distinctive designs and colors that made them stand out on store shelves.

The Elements line was discontinued in the early 2000s, though Snapple brought back a reformulated version in 2008 that wasn't quite the same. The original Elements had a devoted following who appreciated the more complex flavors and the beautiful bottle design.

1

The helmet catch

Image: Lucas Andrade

In Super Bowl XLII, with the Patriots seconds away from winning a perfect match, Giants receiver David Tyree made an impossible grab by pinning the football against his helmet as he fell .

To this day, fans call it the greatest "miracle catch" in championship history, a moment that proved even the unbeatable can be beaten.

2

The infamous wardrobe malfunction

Image: Anders Krøgh Jørgensen

At the 2004 halftime show, Justin Timberlake tore part of Janet Jackson’s costume , revealing more than intended before a live worldwide audience. The moment lasted half a second but changed broadcasting rules forever.

Outrage, apologies, and fines followed, turning that split second into a pop-culture synonym for live-TV mishaps.

3

Prince in the rain

Image: Manos Gkikas

4

When Prince took the stage at Super Bowl XLI, thunder rolled, and rain began to pour . Instead of retreating, His Royal Badness leaned into the storm, closing with "Purple Rain." 

Viewers still recall that electric silhouette in the drizzle: a performer literally singing through his own anthem, transforming bad weather into living symbolism of showmanship.

5

Whitney Houston’s anthem

Image: Anders Krøgh Jørgensen

In 1991, Whitney Houston opened Super Bowl XXV with a rendition of "The Star-Spangled Banner" so powerful it eclipsed the game.

That performance was replayed on the radio, released as a single, and later revived for charity, proof that a national anthem could become a timeless pop classic.

6

Beyoncé and the blackout

Image: Emily Bauman

Super Bowl XLVII’s halftime show is remembered by Beyoncé’s choreography, fireworks, and sheer voltage. Minutes after her final pose, half the stadium lights failed .

Fans joked she blew the fuse herself, and the event worked to her advantage, turning a technical glitch into an incredible moment.

7

The Budweiser frogs

Image: gary tresize

During the 1995 broadcast, three computer-animated frogs croaked "Bud… Weis… Er." The simple rhythm and humor made the ad an overnight sensation.

Viewers repeated it endlessly, making what was a simple ad (albeit a very expensive one) into a cultural phenomenon of its day.

8

The Philly Special

Image: Myron Mott

With the Eagles facing the Patriots in 2018, quarterback Nick Foles pulled off the unthinkable: catching a touchdown pass himself on a fourth-down trick play .

Dubbed the "Philly Special," it symbolized daring over doubt. Philadelphia celebrated its first title as fans shouted that a backup QB had outmaneuvered Tom Brady in football’s biggest game.

9

Shakira & J.Lo together

Image: Alexander Wark Feeney

In 2020, Latin superstars Shakira and Jennifer Lopez performed together during Miami’s halftime . From swirling dance moves to a surprise cameo by J.Lo’s daughter, it was a cultural statement.

The show fused salsa, rock, and pop with Latin symbolism, leaving audiences buzzing with music and color.

10

The 28–3 impossible comeback

Image: Fredrick Lee

When Atlanta led 28–3 in 2017, viewers assumed Tom Brady’s Patriots were finished. Then came a jaw-dropping rally: overtime, a final drive, and a 34–28 victory. 

It became the greatest comeback in Super Bowl history, a lesson in patience and belief, replayed whenever anyone wants proof that no lead is truly safe when Brady is behind center.

11

The King of Pop takes over

Image: Call Me Fred

Before 1993, halftime shows were novelty acts. Then came Michael Jackson, standing motionless for a full minute before launching into "Billie Jean." Ratings skyrocketed.

The spectacle turned halftime into prime-time entertainment. Every star since, from U2 to Rihanna, has followed in that path.

12

U2’s 9/11 tribute

Image: Roberto Rendon

Just months after the September 11 attacks, U2’s halftime show in 2002 honored victims as their names scrolled behind the band . Bono opened his jacket to reveal an American-flag lining.

Viewers remember the quiet tears as much as the songs, a moment where football yielded to shared mourning and hope.

13

A left shark dances on

Image: Adam Rutkowski

14

Katy Perry’s 2015 halftime delivered pyrotechnics, flying stars, and a confused blue shark dancer. While "Right Shark" hit every beat, "Left Shark" flailed endearingly off-tempo. 

Within hours, he became an internet hero, proving that even in a multimillion-dollar production, spontaneity and silliness can steal the spotlight from perfection.